A contractor started seven adjudications in one month and won three of them. It still ended up with a court judgment against it for more than £1.6 million. Avanton v LUC Construction, decided on 15 October 2026, is a sharp lesson in adjudication enforcement: a missed notice can outweigh a run of wins on valuation, and the court will rarely delay payment [1][2].
Key Takeaways
- Pay now, argue later still rules. The court enforced the adjudicator's decision and refused a stay [1][2].
- Notices matter more than merits at this stage. The decisive adjudication was about a missing payment or pay less notice [2].
- A stay needs proof, not worry. The paying party must show the other side would probably be unable to repay [1][2].
- Pleading poverty is rarely enough. A party's own inability to pay justifies a stay only in exceptional cases [2].
- Know who you are contracting with. Dealing with a thinly funded company is a risk taken at the start.
The Facts in Avanton v LUC Construction
Avanton Capital CC Limited is a special purpose vehicle (SPV). It engaged LUC Construction Limited under a November 2023 design and build contract for three industrial units at Culvert Court, London [1]. Practical completion was certified on 10 April 2025, and a final account dispute followed [2].
In May 2026, LUC started seven adjudications before seven adjudicators, each on a different valuation issue [2]. Avanton started one of its own, saying LUC had failed to serve a valid payment or pay less notice [2].
| Adjudication | Result |
|---|---|
| Three of LUC's seven | Avanton's contra charges found overstated by a total of £710,264 [1][2] |
| The other four | The adjudicators resigned [2] |
| Avanton's | LUC ordered to pay the notified sum of £1,877,640.25, plus interest and fees [1][2] |
Avanton applied to the Technology and Construction Court for summary judgment. LUC asked for a stay of execution.
The Decision: No Stay
Constable J gave judgment for Avanton for £1,603,500.25 plus interest, after a set-off of £184,140 from a separate award, plus £13,742 in adjudicator's fees [1].
LUC made two arguments for a stay. Both failed.
Argument one: Avanton could not repay
LUC said that if it later won in arbitration, Avanton would probably be unable to repay. The court applied the established principles from Wimbledon Construction v Vago [1][2].
Avanton was an SPV with little cash that relied on discretionary funding from its group. But LUC had not proved that repayment was improbable. There had been historic group support of about £4,157,000, the parent had positive net assets, and there was evidence that support would continue [1][2]. LUC had also always known it was contracting with a limited-asset SPV [2].
Argument two: LUC itself could not pay
LUC said paying would force it to stop trading. The judge accepted that a defendant's own inability to pay can be relevant, but only exceptionally. LUC's evidence did not deal with other sources of funds, including its 50% shareholder [1][2]. That gap was fatal.
Where the competing risks of injustice are finely balanced, the court should generally enforce.
The court also rejected the idea that two parties' money troubles cancel each other out [1]. And favourable decisions in other adjudications did not stop enforcement of the adverse one [2].
Avanton v LUC Construction Adjudication Enforcement: Practical Lessons
For employers and building owners
- Serve payment notices and pay less notices on time, every time.
- Keep clear records behind every contra charge. Three adjudicators found these overstated.
- Expect to pay an adjudicator's award promptly, even if a later tribunal may reverse it.
For contractors
- A notified sum falls due if the right notices are not served. Winning valuation points elsewhere does not change that.
- Before signing, check the other party's financial strength. Consider a parent company guarantee or other security when the client is an SPV.
- If a stay is sought, give full evidence of every realistic source of funds.
For quantity surveyors and building surveyors
- Diary every notice date under the contract.
- Build valuations that can be explained line by line.
- Keep site records, photographs and measured quantities in order from day one.
Expert Evidence in Final Account and Defects Disputes
Adjudication is fast, but it still runs on evidence. Quantity surveyors give expert opinion on valuation, variations and contra charges. Building surveyors report on defects, cause and reasonable repair. The same evidence often reappears in a later arbitration or court claim.
In court, CPR Part 35 makes the expert's overriding duty one owed to the court. Surveyors should also note that the RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition, takes effect on 30 November 2026. Its definition of "tribunal" expressly includes construction adjudication, so the duty of independence applies there too [3].
For developers and contractors working in Kingston upon Thames and south-west London, the message is the same as anywhere else: get the notices right and keep the evidence ready.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did LUC have to pay after winning three adjudications?
Because Avanton's adjudication was about notices. Without a valid payment or pay less notice, the notified sum was due [2].
What is a stay of execution?
An order delaying enforcement of a judgment. In adjudication cases it is granted only in limited circumstances [1][2].
Can a party avoid paying because it cannot afford to?
Only exceptionally, and only with full evidence of all possible sources of funds [2].
Is the dispute over?
The final account can still be decided finally in arbitration. The judgment enforces the adjudicator's decision in the meantime [2].
Conclusion
Avanton v LUC Construction confirms how firmly the courts back adjudication. Notices decide who pays first. A stay is hard to get. And the financial strength of the other party should be checked before the contract is signed, not after the dispute begins.
Owners, contractors and their surveyors should review their notice procedures and record-keeping now.
This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Take advice on your own circumstances.
References
- Mayer Brown, "Legal Developments in Construction Law: November 2026" (16 November 2026). mayerbrown.com.
- Fenwick Elliott, Dispatch Issue 316, "Avanton Capital CC Ltd v LUC Construction Ltd" (28 October 2026). fenwickelliott.com.
- RICS, Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition (July 2026, effective 30 November 2026). rics.org.




