Less than half a metre of kitchen floor took two neighbours in Surbiton to a two-day tribunal hearing. The strip is about 480mm wide. One side said it was a trespass and threatened an injunction. The other said it had been part of their home for more than 20 years. In Sharma & Deeley v James (2026) UKFTT 1354 (PC), the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) sided with the owners of the kitchen [1]. For anyone looking for a boundary dispute surveyor in Kingston, the decision is a local and very practical case study.
Key Takeaways
- The kitchen stays where it is. The owners of 26 Cottage Grove, Surbiton, were held to have acquired the disputed strip by adverse possession.
- A house extension is strong evidence of possession. The judge called occupation by a building "possibly the plainest example" of factual possession.
- Reasonable belief was the real fight. The applicants had to show ten years of possession in the reasonable belief that the land was theirs. They relied on the belief of the previous owners from 2000 to 2012.
- Title plans show general boundaries only. Neither side had ever had the exact line determined.
- Several surveys missed the point. Two pre-purchase reports on the neighbouring house in 2021 raised no boundary issue. A later sketch did.
Background: two Victorian semis and a stepped wall
Numbers 25 and 26 Cottage Grove, Surbiton KT6, are adjoining semi-detached Victorian houses. The tribunal thought they were probably formed by dividing one original cottage. Mina Sharma and Neil Deeley bought No. 26 on 31 May 2012. Mrs James bought No. 25 on 25 June 2021.
The disputed land is a "sliver" about 480mm wide. It forms part of the kitchen of No. 26, and possibly part of the bathroom next to it. On the neighbour's case, the true legal boundary was a straight line carrying on from the central roof line, and the kitchen stepped across it.
On 22 November 2022 the owner of No. 25 sent a solicitors' letter alleging trespass and threatening a mandatory injunction and damages. The owners of No. 26 applied to HM Land Registry to be registered as owners of the strip. The objection sent the matter to the tribunal. Judge Ewan Paton made a site visit on 25 August 2026, heard the case on 26 and 27 August, and gave his decision on 9 September 2026.
The legal test for a boundary strip
Since the Land Registration Act 2002, it has been hard to gain registered land by adverse possession. One of the few routes left is the "boundary condition" in paragraph 5(4) of Schedule 6. In broad terms the applicant must show that:
- the land is next to land the applicant already owns;
- the exact line of the boundary has not been determined under the Act;
- the applicant, or a predecessor, was in adverse possession for at least ten years; and
- during that time they reasonably believed the land belonged to them.
The tribunal found that the kitchen had stood in its present position since before 2000. That settled possession. The contest was about belief.
Whose belief counted
In 2019 the owners of No. 26 engaged a professional to measure the house and draw plans. His drawing laid the Land Registry general boundary over the floor plan, and the mismatch appeared. According to the evidence, he also said he was "not a boundary expert".
The applicants accepted that their own reasonable belief ended at that point, in September 2019. That was less than ten years after they bought. So they relied on the previous owners, Mr and Mrs Wallace, who owned No. 26 from 2000 to 2012.
The judge accepted that the Wallaces truly believed they owned the whole kitchen and that the belief was reasonable. He applied the approach in IAM Group Plc v Chowdrey, sometimes summed up as "what you see is what you get". A buyer who is shown a house with a kitchen inside its walls has no reason to suspect that part of the room belongs next door.
The tribunal found that the boundary had "likely been in its current location for well over 22 years" before anyone complained. A suggestion that the applicants had demolished a wall was withdrawn and rejected.
The survey evidence: what was and was not picked up
No single joint expert was appointed, and the decision does not record any surveyor giving oral expert evidence. Even so, survey documents run right through the story.
| Document | Date | What it showed |
|---|---|---|
| Mortgage valuation of No. 26 | February 2012 | A lender's valuation, not a detailed survey. Neither the valuer nor the report was in evidence |
| Measured plans of No. 26 | 2019 | First overlay of the title plan on the floor plan; mismatch noticed |
| Survey of No. 25 for an earlier buyer | March 2021 | No boundary issue raised |
| Structural survey of No. 25 | April 2021 | No boundary issue raised |
| Surveyors' inspection and sketch for No. 25 | May 2022 | Discrepancy raised. The tribunal noted the sketch also showed an inset on No. 25's own side |
Three points stand out for owners and for surveyors.
A mortgage valuation is not a boundary check. It exists to tell the lender the property is adequate security. It will rarely compare walls on the ground with the title plan.
A building survey is not a boundary survey either. A RICS Level 2 or Level 3 survey reports on condition. It may flag an obvious mismatch, but it does not plot the legal boundary.
A sketch is a starting point, not proof. The 2022 sketch began the dispute. It did not win it. The tribunal looked at how long the walls had stood and what a reasonable owner would have believed.
What this means for a boundary dispute surveyor in Kingston and Surbiton
Converted cottages, split plots and shared flank walls are common across Surbiton, Kingston and the surrounding area. This decision suggests a sensible order of work when a mismatch appears.
- Check the history before sending a letter. Old planning files, building control records, sales particulars and photographs can show how long a wall has been in place.
- Remember the general boundaries rule. The red line on a title plan is not a precise measurement. A thick line at 1:1250 can cover a strip wider than the one fought over here.
- Instruct the right kind of surveyor. A measured survey that plots physical features against the title documents needs a surveyor with boundary experience. If the case may be litigated, the surveyor must also understand the duty of independence owed to the tribunal.
- Think about costs. The tribunal said costs follow the event, to be assessed on the standard basis against the unsuccessful respondents. A threat of an injunction over 480mm proved an expensive opening move.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a neighbour really gain land by building on it?
In limited cases, yes. Where the exact boundary has never been determined and the occupier reasonably believed the land was theirs for ten years, the Land Registration Act 2002 allows registration.
Does the ten years have to be the applicant's own?
No. In this case the applicants relied on the possession and belief of the couple who owned the house before them.
Would a determined boundary have prevented this?
A boundary formally determined at HM Land Registry takes the land outside this route to adverse possession. That is one reason owners sometimes apply to fix the exact line once a dispute is settled.
Should buyers ask for a boundary check?
Where walls, extensions or fences do not seem to match the title plan, it is worth asking a surveyor to look before exchange, not after.
Conclusion
Sharma v James shows that long-standing walls usually carry more weight than a line on a plan, and that the first professional to spot a mismatch is not always the last word on it.
Owners in Kingston and Surbiton who find a discrepancy should gather the history, take advice from a surveyor with boundary experience, and try to settle the line by agreement before positions harden. Buyers should read the title plan against the building at viewing stage and raise questions early.
This article is general information on a recent decision and is not legal advice.
References
- Sharma & Deeley v James (2026) UKFTT 1354 (PC). caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.




