Two reports said poor workmanship. One said poor installation and partial replacement. The next said the system was never designed for the job and had to come out entirely. By the time the fifth set of advisers gave a view, the contractor had already settled with the architect for £1,575,000. Could it sue again for more than £7 million? On 3 November 2026 the Technology and Construction Court said yes, for now. United Living (South) Ltd v Dovista UK Ltd and others is essential reading for anyone instructed as a building defects claim expert witness, because the sequence of expert reports was the spine of the whole argument [1].
Key Takeaways
- Mr Justice Eyre dismissed the architect Hawkins Brown's application to strike out or obtain summary judgment on a claim worth over £7 million relating to the Wenlock Building in London N1.
- A March 2023 settlement under which the architect paid £1,575,000 covered only the claims then live, so the new claims were not compromised.
- The claimant was not guilty of abuse of process. At the time of settlement it knew the curtain-walling system needed replacing and that a further claim was possible, but the judge found this was a potential claim needing investigation, not one it had decided to bring.
- The chronology of technical reports, from Wintech in 2020 to HKA in 2023, was central to when the claim was treated as known.
- For expert witnesses, the case shows how early advisory reports are later dissected for what they said, what they did not say and what they recommended.
The project and the defects
United Living (South) Ltd, formerly United House Ltd, carried out the conversion of 50 to 60 Wharf Road, London N1 into the Wenlock Building. The alleged defects concern fire safety and environmental performance problems in the Velfac curtain-walling system and inadequate fire protection of structural steel at upper levels. The claimant had earlier settled a related claim brought against it by Workspace 14 Ltd [1].
The defendants were Dovista UK Ltd, formerly Velfac Ltd, the window-system supplier, which took a neutral stance; Dantaag Ltd, which did not appear; and Hawkins Brown Ltd, the architect, which made the application [1].
The claim is valued at over £7 million: an estimated £3.142 million to replace the Velfac system and £4.209 million to remediate the structural steel [1].
The five expert reports that shaped the building defects claim
| Report or advice | Date | What it said |
|---|---|---|
| Wintech Façade Engineering | September 2020 and April 2021 | Relied on by the architect as pointing to poor workmanship rather than design failure |
| PS Fixing | November 2022 | Poor installation; recommended replacing parts of the system |
| Fire engineering and building control emails | December 2022 | Raised fire protection concerns about the steel structure |
| Status A | January 2023 | System never designed for its use; full replacement the only viable solution |
| HKA Global | January and March 2023 | Preliminary views that there were grounds for a claim against the architect |
Earlier proceedings against the architect were settled by a Settlement Agreement dated 20 March 2023, under which Hawkins Brown paid £1,575,000. The claimant later concluded that the Velfac system needed full replacement, sent a letter of claim in May 2024 and issued the current proceedings in 2024 [1].
What the architect argued
Hawkins Brown ran three arguments: that the new claims were an abuse of process under the Henderson v Henderson and Johnson v Gore Wood line of authority; that they had been compromised by the 2023 settlement; and that the claimant was estopped from bringing them [1].
What Mr Justice Eyre decided
The hearing took place on 21 and 22 July 2026 with further written submissions on 29 July 2026 [1].
Settlement
The settlement covered only the claims that were live in the earlier proceedings. The new claims were therefore not compromised, and summary judgment on that basis was refused [1].
Estoppel
The representation relied on was not adequately particularised, and the entire agreement clause weighed heavily against the argument. Summary judgment was refused and the court declined to order a preliminary issue [1].
Abuse of process
By the time of the second mediation and the settlement in February and March 2023, the claimant knew the Velfac system would have to be replaced and knew there was scope to argue that the system was inherently unsuitable. The judge nonetheless found that this was only a potential claim requiring further investigation, not a claim the claimant had decided to bring. He accepted the assessment of Mr Forsyth as to the further steps that were needed, describing those points as realistic. The Aldi guidelines were not engaged because the potential claim was too speculative to require an application to the court. There was no abuse. Had abuse been found, the judge said he would have struck the claim out [1].
The application was dismissed [1].
The judge drew a line between knowing a problem exists and knowing you have a claim worth bringing. Expert reports sit on both sides of that line.
Lessons for the building defects claim expert witness
Expert reports in this case were not written for a trial. They were investigative and advisory documents produced over three years. Yet each one was later examined for what it established and when. Several lessons follow.
Record the scope and the question asked
Wintech's reports were relied on by the architect as pointing to workmanship rather than design. Whether that is a fair reading depends on what Wintech was asked to assess. An expert who states the question, the extent of inspection and the limits of the opinion protects both the client and the expert's own later credibility.
Distinguish observation from diagnosis
PS Fixing observed poor installation and recommended partial replacement. Status A diagnosed a system never designed for its use. Those are different kinds of conclusion, and each carries a different legal consequence. Experts should make clear which they are offering.
Preliminary views are still evidence
HKA's provisional indication in January 2023 that there might be scope for a claim became a key date in the abuse of process analysis. A preliminary view should be labelled as such, with the further steps needed to firm it up spelled out. Here, Mr Forsyth's account of those steps was accepted as realistic and helped the claimant.
Advisory report versus CPR Part 35 report
None of the reports listed above appears to have been a formal Part 35 expert report. When the matter proceeds, the parties will need independent expert evidence on façade engineering, fire engineering and quantum that complies with CPR Part 35 and Practice Direction 35: a statement of instructions, the material relied on, the range of opinion and a statement of truth. The RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition, effective from 30 November 2026, applies the same discipline to chartered surveyors, including the duty to the court over the instructing party.
What this means for building owners and leaseholders in Kingston and south-west London
Owners of converted and new-build blocks across Kingston upon Thames, Surbiton and New Malden face similar questions when cladding, curtain walling or fire protection problems emerge in stages.
- An early report that blames workmanship does not close the door on a later design claim, but it will be scrutinised.
- Settling with one party for one set of defects does not automatically release that party from other defects, but the settlement wording decides it. Read the release clause carefully.
- Keep every report, email and site note. The chronology will matter years later.
What this means for surveyors and solicitors
- Building surveyors instructed to investigate defects should state scope, method, access limitations and the confidence level of each conclusion.
- Solicitors drafting settlement agreements should define the claims released by reference to the defects known at the time and consider carve-outs for matters still under investigation.
- Where a potential further claim is identified during settlement, document the steps still needed to evaluate it. That record can be decisive in a later abuse of process argument.
Conclusion
United Living v Dovista and Hawkins\Brown is an interim decision. The £7.4 million claim will now be fought on its merits, and the court will hear proper expert evidence on whether the Velfac system and the steel protection were defective and why. The judgment already carries a clear message for every building defects claim expert witness: your early reports are never just advice. They become the timeline the court uses to decide what the parties knew and when. The full judgment is on the National Archives Find Case Law service [1].




