RICS Consults on ‘AI in Real Estate Valuation’ Until 15 December 2026: What AI-Assisted Valuations Mean for Down-Valuations, Red Book Reports and Valuation Disputes in Kingston upon Thames (November 2026)

{"content":[]}

A valuer in Kingston upon Thames can now have comparables screened, a draft report written and the figures sense-checked by software before the kettle has boiled. That is exactly the situation RICS is trying to get ahead of. On 3 November 2026 it opened the AI in real estate valuation RICS consultation, inviting comments on a draft practice guidance, 'AI in real estate valuation, 1st edition', until 23:59 on 15 December 2026 [1]. For anyone buying, selling or remortgaging in Kingston, Surbiton or New Malden, the question is simple: if a machine helped produce the valuation that knocked £30,000 off your mortgage offer, who is responsible for it, and how do you challenge it?

This article explains what RICS has published, what the draft covers, and what it means for down-valuations, Red Book reports and valuation disputes in south-west London. It is general information, not legal or financial advice.

Key Takeaways

  • RICS is consulting on draft practice guidance on AI in real estate valuation from 3 November to 15 December 2026, and wants to know whether the draft is clear, well structured and complete [1].
  • The draft follows the whole valuation lifecycle, from instruction and terms of engagement through analysis to reporting and record keeping, and covers firm governance, tool selection, data and model risk, vendor due diligence, training and supervision [1].
  • RICS says the consultation is not about whether AI should be used at all, but whether the guidance gives balanced, practical and proportionate support to those who use, oversee, procure or rely on AI-assisted valuation work [1].
  • The valuer still signs the report. Professional judgement, scepticism and accountability remain with the RICS member, however much software was involved [1].
  • For Kingston homeowners, the practical effect will be felt in down-valuation challenges and valuation disputes, where the records behind an AI-assisted figure will be tested.

What RICS has published and when the AI in real estate valuation RICS consultation closes

The consultation sits on the RICS iConsult platform. It opened at 06:00 on 3 November 2026 and closes at 23:59 on 15 December 2026. Members and other stakeholders can comment on the draft section by section, answer an online questionnaire, or both, and a full PDF of the draft is available to download [1].

RICS's starting point is that AI is now embedded in the everyday tools of valuation practice, including drafting, document review, data screening, modelling, quality assurance and reporting, and the draft's purpose is to help members and regulated firms use those tools responsibly while keeping professional judgement, scepticism and accountability [1].

What the draft practice guidance covers across the valuation lifecycle

The draft builds on two existing pillars: the RICS professional standard on the responsible use of AI in surveying practice, and the requirements already set out in the Red Book [1]. It applies those principles specifically to real estate valuation and tracks the lifecycle of an instruction:

  • Instruction and terms of engagement. How AI-assisted work is agreed with the client at the outset.
  • Analysis. How tools that screen data, select comparables or model values are used and checked.
  • Reporting. How the output is presented so that the client, and anyone relying on the report, understands what was done.
  • Record keeping. What the file should contain so that the valuation can be explained later.

At firm level, the draft also deals with governance, tool selection, data and model risk, vendor due diligence, training and supervision [1].

RICS is explicit that the exercise 'is not intended to test support for AI in principle'. The test is whether the draft gives 'balanced, practical and proportionate support' to those who use, oversee, procure or rely on AI-assisted valuation work [1]. That last group includes lenders, solicitors, courts and homeowners.

How AI is already used in valuation: AVMs, desktop valuations, comparables and drafting

Automated valuation models have been part of lending for years, and desktop valuations without a physical inspection are routine for lower-risk remortgages. Our guide to Desktop Valuation vs Physical Survey: UK Lender Guide 2026 explains when lenders accept remote valuations and when they will not.

None of this removes the need for an inspection where the Red Book and the terms of engagement require one, and it does not change the Red Book's expectation that valuations are carried out by competent, independent valuers who inspect and investigate appropriately and give a reasoned report [2]. If you are unsure what that involves, see What Is a Red Book Valuation? | RICS Valuations Explained.

Why the AI in real estate valuation RICS consultation matters for down-valuations in Kingston

A down-valuation happens when the lender's valuer reports a figure below the agreed price, and in Kingston the comparables chosen make all the difference.

The draft's emphasis on record keeping and model risk is therefore good news for buyers and sellers: a valuer who follows the guidance should be able to show which comparables were considered, why some were rejected and what adjustments were made, whether the first cut came from software or not [1].

Our article on Surveyor Reports in Mortgage Lending: Approval & Down-Valuations explains how lender reports feed into offers, and How to Challenge a Red Book Valuation Safely sets out how to question a figure without derailing a sale or remortgage.

The valuer signs the report. The software does not. That is the principle the draft is built around, and it is the principle a challenge should be built around too.

Professional judgement, scepticism and accountability: the valuer still signs the report

The draft's three words are worth repeating: judgement, scepticism, accountability [1]. In practice they mean:

  1. Judgement. The valuer decides, and must be able to explain, why the figure is what it is.
  2. Scepticism. Tidy output is not the same as correct output; data gaps, unusual properties and local factors a model cannot see need human attention.
  3. Accountability. Responsibility stays with the RICS member and the regulated firm, including those who oversee and procure tools [1].

RICS's Standards and Regulation Board said in its Q3 update of 10 September 2026 that it is already checking how the responsible-use-of-AI professional standard is being implemented at regulated firms during review visits, with findings to be published in early 2027 [3]. The valuation guidance will sit inside that regulatory framework.

Record keeping, model risk and vendor due diligence: what a challenged valuation will need to show

A challenged valuation, whether disputed by a buyer, a divorcing couple or an executor facing an HMRC enquiry, is only as good as its file. The draft's lifecycle approach points to a file that records the terms of engagement, the tools used and the due diligence done on their vendors, the data and its limitations, the human adjustments to any model output, the quality assurance performed, and the training and supervision of the people involved [1].

Expert valuation evidence in disputes: how AI-assisted work will be tested

When a valuation ends up in court or a tribunal, the valuer's duty is to the court, and the report has to withstand cross-examination. Courts have generally accepted that competent valuers can reasonably differ, and that a valuation falling within a margin, often described as a bracket of around 5 to 15 per cent depending on the property, is not negligent simply because another valuer would have reached a different figure. The bracket is not a safe harbour for poor method, however. A valuer who cannot explain how the figure was reached is exposed whatever the number.

AI-assisted work raises specific questions that any expert valuer should expect:

  • Which parts of the analysis were produced by a tool, and were they disclosed?
  • Did the valuer verify the comparables the tool selected?
  • Was the model appropriate for the property type and location?
  • Where are the records showing the human review?

An AI-assisted valuation that follows the draft guidance on reporting and record keeping [1] and the Red Book's requirement for a reasoned report [2] should be easier to defend; one that cannot show its workings will be easier to attack.

What buyers, sellers and lenders in Kingston should do now

  • Buyers facing a down-valuation. Ask the lender how the valuation was produced, obtain your own independent Red Book valuation, and challenge the figure with evidence rather than frustration.
  • Sellers. Price on evidence. An independent valuation before marketing reduces the risk of a lender's figure falling short at the eleventh hour.
  • Valuers. Respond to the consultation before 15 December 2026 and review file practices against the lifecycle the draft describes.

How Kingston Surveyors can help with independent Red Book valuations

Kingston Surveyors is an RICS practice serving Kingston upon Thames, Surbiton, New Malden, Richmond and south-west London. Its registered valuers provide independent Red Book valuations for mortgage challenges, lease extensions, matrimonial and probate matters, and expert valuation evidence for disputes. Every report records its comparables, adjustments and reasoning so that it can be explained to a lender, a solicitor or a court.

FAQ

Is RICS banning AI in valuation?

No. RICS says the consultation is not intended to test support for AI in principle. The draft is about using AI tools responsibly while keeping professional judgement, scepticism and accountability with the valuer [1].

When does the consultation close and who can respond?

It closes at 23:59 on 15 December 2026. RICS invites members and other stakeholders to comment on the draft section by section or complete a questionnaire on iConsult [1].

What happens after the consultation?

RICS says the author, its expert group and RICS will review all feedback, make agreed updates, and take the final practice guidance through RICS governance, including review by the Knowledge and Practice Committee, before publication [1].

Can a down-valuation in Kingston be challenged if software chose the comparables?

Yes. The valuer remains responsible for the figure, so a challenge should focus on the comparables used, the adjustments made and the local evidence, supported by an independent Red Book valuation.

Conclusion

The AI in real estate valuation RICS consultation marks the point at which AI-assisted valuation stops being an informal practice and becomes a regulated one. The draft does not remove tools from the valuer's desk; it asks for judgement, scepticism and accountability at every stage, from engagement letter to filing cabinet [1]. For Kingston homeowners, the practical message is that a valuation, however it was produced, must be explainable. In the meantime, anyone facing a disputed figure should obtain independent, fully reasoned Red Book advice and insist that the workings behind the number are shown.

References

  1. Consultationhome. consultations.rics.org.
  2. Red Book. rics.org.
  3. Upholding Standards and Professionalism Srb Q3 Update. rics.org.
Kingston Surveyors logo
Copyright ©2024 Kingston Surveyors