McLean v Winchester Medical Aesthetics (2026) EWHC 2941 (TCC): A £25,000 Building Dispute, £14,113 in Adjudicator’s Fees and £37,664 in Costs, Construction Adjudication Lessons for Kingston Property Owners (November 2026)

Adjudication is promoted as the quick and affordable way to resolve a building dispute. A judgment handed down in the Technology and Construction Court in Leeds on 13 November 2026 shows how badly it can go for a small business that starts the process without understanding what it is signing up to.

In McLean and Expert Architect Studio LLP v Winchester Medical Aesthetics Ltd (2026) EWHC 2941 (TCC), Her Honour Judge Kelly gave summary judgment for an adjudicator who sued for his unpaid fees. The business that had started the adjudication, seeking a refund of a little over £25,000 from its building contractor, now owes the adjudicator's fees of £14,113.44, further fees for the time he spent recovering them, contractual interest and legal costs of £37,664.30.

For business owners and landlords in Kingston fitting out or refurbishing commercial premises, the case is worth ten minutes.

What happened

Winchester Medical engaged a contractor to carry out construction works at its premises. The contract was terminated around November 2024. Winchester Medical said the work was inadequate and wanted back more than £25,000 it had paid.

The contract contained no dispute resolution clause. For a construction contract that means the statutory Scheme for Construction Contracts applies, and either party can refer a dispute to adjudication at any time. On 21 January 2025 Winchester Medical served a notice of adjudication and asked the Royal Institute of British Architects to nominate an adjudicator, which it did within days.

The adjudicator sent his terms to both parties. Both signed and returned them without objection. The terms provided for:

  • an hourly rate of £324 plus VAT and disbursements;
  • invoices payable within seven days;
  • interest on late payment at 8% above Bank of England base rate;
  • recovery of the legal and other costs of pursuing unpaid invoices;
  • joint and several liability of both parties for the fees, so that the adjudicator could look to either of them for the whole amount.

The adjudicator gave his decision on 7 March 2025. Winchester Medical did not pay his fees. He issued a claim on 7 November 2025.

The defences, and why each failed

The company was represented at the hearing by its director in person. It raised seven lines of defence. None had a realistic prospect of success.

Jurisdiction and natural justice

The company said the adjudicator had acted outside his jurisdiction and unfairly. The judge held that even if that were established, it would not answer a claim for fees. The adjudicator's right to be paid arises under his contract with the parties and applies whether or not his decision is enforceable between them. She also noted that the threshold for a natural justice challenge in adjudication is high.

Bias and bad faith

Allegations of this kind need clear particulars and strong evidence. The judge found none. The adjudicator's account of his process was consistent with his decision.

No site visit

The company complained that the adjudicator refused to visit the premises despite the seriousness of the alleged defects and the limits of photographs. The judge held that whether to hold a site visit is a procedural decision for the adjudicator.

Unfair terms

The argument that the terms were not fairly incorporated or were unreasonable failed. The terms had been signed. There was no inequality of bargaining power, since the company could have declined the appointment. The terms were not onerous or unusual, and joint and several liability for an adjudicator's fees has been approved by the Court of Appeal.

Excessive fees

The hourly rate and the hours were found to be reasonable and supported by contemporaneous timesheets. The judge noted that both parties had sent the adjudicator large amounts of irrelevant material, all of which he had to consider. The company did not dispute that the hours had been worked and put forward no positive case on what a reasonable time would have been.

Penalty

The adjudicator had offered a discount of one third for prompt payment. The company said that losing the discount was a penalty. The judge disagreed: it was an offer to reduce the fees, not a penalty clause.

The winding-up petition

An earlier winding-up petition had been restrained by injunction. The judge held that this was irrelevant, because the test on a winding-up petition is different from whether a defence has a realistic prospect of success.

The bill

Summary judgment was given for:

  • £14,113.44 in fees up to the decision;
  • £5,093.28 for time spent pursuing recovery up to the application;
  • £1,671.84 for further time since the application;
  • interest at 8% above base rate;
  • legal costs of £37,664.30.

The judge said the costs were reasonable, and possibly higher than they would otherwise have been because of the company's unmeritorious and wide-ranging submissions.

A dispute over roughly £25,000 has produced a liability for fees and costs of more than twice that, before interest.

Lessons for property owners and small businesses

Adjudication is not free, and the referring party is on the hook

Whoever wins, the adjudicator is entitled to be paid, and his terms will almost always make both parties liable for the whole fee. If the other side does not pay, you will.

Read the terms before you sign them

An hourly rate, a short payment period, commercial interest and a right to recover collection costs are all standard. If the likely fee is out of proportion to the sum in dispute, that is the moment to consider a different route.

Keep submissions short and relevant

The adjudicator charges for reading what he is sent. Hundreds of pages of emails add cost and rarely add weight.

Do not expect a site visit

Adjudications are often decided on documents within 28 days. If you say work is defective, you need to prove it on paper.

Get the defects evidence right before you start

This is where a chartered building surveyor earns the fee. A defects claim in adjudication should rest on:

  • a dated inspection report describing each defect, its location and extent;
  • clear photographs tied to a marked-up plan;
  • reference to the contract specification, drawings or relevant standards the work fails to meet;
  • a costed schedule of remedial works.

An adjudicator given that material can decide the dispute without visiting. An adjudicator given only complaints and phone photographs may not be persuaded.

Consider proportionate alternatives

For modest sums, a jointly instructed surveyor's report, mediation or a small claim in the County Court may resolve the matter at lower risk. Legal advice before serving a notice of adjudication is money well spent.

Put a dispute clause in the contract

The company's contract had no dispute resolution mechanism, so the statutory Scheme applied by default. A written contract with a clear specification, payment terms and an agreed dispute procedure avoids surprises.

A note for Kingston landlords and occupiers

The statutory right to adjudicate applies to construction contracts for commercial premises: shop fit-outs, clinic and office refurbishments, restaurant conversions. It does not generally apply to a contract with a homeowner for work on their own home unless the contract provides for it. If you are a homeowner in dispute with a builder, your options are different and usually start with a surveyor's report and a letter of claim.

How Kingston Surveyors can help

We inspect and report on defective and incomplete building work across Kingston upon Thames, Surbiton and New Malden, prepare costed schedules of remedial works, and provide independent evidence for adjudication, mediation and court proceedings.

Frequently asked questions

What did the court decide in McLean v Winchester Medical Aesthetics?

On 13 November 2026 the Technology and Construction Court gave summary judgment for an adjudicator claiming unpaid fees, further fees for recovery, interest and legal costs of £37,664.30 against the company that had started the adjudication.

Who pays the adjudicator's fees in a construction adjudication?

The adjudicator usually decides how his fees are split, but his terms normally make both parties jointly and severally liable, so he can recover the whole amount from either.

Does an adjudicator have to visit the site?

No. The court confirmed that whether to hold a site visit is a procedural matter for the adjudicator.

Can a challenge to the adjudicator's decision be used to avoid paying his fees?

Not in this case. The judge held that the contractual right to fees applied whether or not the decision was enforceable between the parties.

This article is a general summary of a published judgment for information only and is not legal advice.

Kingston Surveyors logo
Copyright ©2024 Kingston Surveyors