A tenant paid the rent invoice its landlord's agents sent. Then, at three o'clock on the Friday before the break date, a demand for insurance rent was hand-delivered to the premises while the tenant's representative was supervising final dilapidations work. The landlord later argued that the lease had never ended. On 20 October 2026 the High Court rejected that argument.
Sterling House Limited v International Baccalaureate Organisation (UK) Limited (2026) EWHC 2680 (BP) was heard in Cardiff on 12 October 2026 by His Honour Judge Jarman KC, sitting as a High Court judge. For commercial landlords, tenants and the surveyors who advise them in Kingston and across south-west London, it is a useful reminder of how break clauses work in practice, and of how often dilapidations and lease exits collide in the last few days of a term.
What happened
The tenant occupied Sterling House, an office building on a business park in Cardiff, and served a break notice to end the lease on 23 February 2026. As is common, the lease made the break conditional: it would be ineffective if sums due under the lease were outstanding at the break date.
The landlord said two sums were outstanding:
- about £45,000 of annual rent, which was payable quarterly in advance; and
- about £2,300 of insurance rent.
The tenant's answer on the first sum lay in the landlord's own paperwork. On 10 February 2026 the landlord's agents sent an invoice for rent covering the period from 22 December 2025 to 23 February 2026. The tenant paid it on 13 February.
The insurance rent demand arrived at 3pm on Friday 20 February 2026. It was delivered by hand to the building, where the tenant's representative was overseeing what the judgment describes as "last minute dilapidations work" on 20 and 23 February. The tenant paid by faster payment on 24 February, the day after the break date.
What the court decided
The landlord's claim was dismissed. The break was effective.
The rent. The agents' invoice was a clear representation of what was due before handover. The tenant relied on it, and that reliance was reasonable. The landlord was prevented by estoppel from asserting that a larger sum had been due.
The insurance rent. A demand delivered on the Friday afternoon before a Monday break date gave the tenant no reasonable time to react. In the alternative, the way the tenant went about paying was reasonable. The landlord was estopped from denying that payment had been made in time.
The judge referred to the earlier decision in PCE Investors Ltd v Cancer Research UK (2012) EWHC 844 (Ch), a well-known authority on conditional break clauses. There was no surveyor or expert evidence in the case, and the court made no ruling about dilapidations.
Why break clauses are policed so strictly
A break clause is an option. The tenant must comply exactly with any conditions attached to it. If the lease says all sums must be paid by the break date, a shortfall of a few pounds can leave the tenant bound for the rest of the term. That is why landlords examine break notices closely, and why this dispute reached the High Court over an insurance demand of around £2,300.
The tenant here succeeded on the facts: an invoice from the landlord's own agents, and a demand served too late to be dealt with sensibly. Tenants should not treat the decision as a safety net. A different set of documents could easily have produced a different result.
Practical lessons for tenants
- Read the break conditions months in advance. Identify every condition: payment, vacant possession, compliance with covenants, notice formalities.
- Ask for a written statement of all sums due. Request it from the landlord or its agents well before the break date, and keep the reply.
- Pay early and pay in cleared funds. If rent is payable in advance for a full quarter, consider paying the full quarter even if the break date falls partway through, unless the lease or the landlord clearly says otherwise.
- Make sure demands reach the right person. Tell the landlord in writing where notices and invoices should be sent during the exit period.
- Do not leave dilapidations to the final week. The representative on site in this case was managing last-minute works when the demand arrived. Late works create exactly the pressure in which things are missed.
The surveyor's role in a lease exit
Dilapidations are the repairing, decorating and reinstatement obligations that fall due at the end of a lease. A chartered building surveyor can take much of the risk out of the exit:
- Early assessment. Twelve to eighteen months before the break or expiry, a surveyor can inspect, review the lease and any licences for alterations, and advise what work is required.
- Programme. Works can then be planned to finish comfortably before the break date, which matters most where the break is conditional on vacant possession or on compliance with covenants.
- Negotiation. If the landlord serves a schedule of dilapidations, the tenant's surveyor responds under the Pre-Action Protocol for Claims for Damages in Relation to the Physical State of Commercial Property at Termination of a Tenancy, usually called the Dilapidations Protocol.
- Valuation. Section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 caps damages for disrepair at the reduction in the value of the landlord's interest. A diminution valuation by a valuer can reduce a claim substantially.
Expert evidence if a dilapidations claim is litigated
Where a terminal dilapidations claim reaches court, each side will usually rely on a building surveyor on the scope and cost of works and often a valuer on diminution in value. Those experts give evidence under CPR Part 35. Their overriding duty is to the court, and their reports must set out the facts and assumptions relied on and give an independent opinion.
Lessons for landlords
- Check what your agents have invoiced before relying on a break condition. A court will hold you to a clear statement of what was due.
- Serve demands in good time. A last-minute demand may not be treated as giving rise to a sum the tenant could reasonably be expected to pay before the break date.
- Instruct a surveyor to prepare the schedule of dilapidations early so that the claim is ready when the term ends.
Kingston Surveyors advises landlords and tenants on schedules of dilapidations, schedules of condition and lease-end strategy across Kingston, Surbiton and south-west London.
Frequently asked questions
What did the court decide in Sterling House v International Baccalaureate Organisation?
The High Court dismissed the landlord's claim that the tenant's break had failed. The tenant had paid the rent invoiced by the landlord's agents, and the insurance rent demand was served too late to give a reasonable time to pay.
Was the case about dilapidations?
Not directly. The court made no ruling on dilapidations. The judgment records that the tenant's representative was supervising last-minute dilapidations work when the insurance rent demand was delivered.
What is a conditional break clause?
It is a right to end a lease early that only takes effect if stated conditions are met, such as payment of all sums due or giving vacant possession. Conditions must be complied with strictly.
When should a tenant instruct a dilapidations surveyor?
Ideally twelve to eighteen months before the break date or lease expiry, so that works can be scoped, priced and completed in good time.
What does section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 do?
It limits damages for breach of a repairing covenant to the amount by which the value of the landlord's interest has been reduced.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Take specific advice on your own circumstances.




