{"content":[]}
A run-down London maisonette was valued at £515,000 for probate, at £800,000 by HMRC, and at £670,000 by the Upper Tribunal. Three figures for one property on one date show how wide a probate valuation dispute can become, and how much turns on the quality of the valuation evidence. The decision in Downey v HMRC [2026] UKUT 228 (LC) was issued on 26 June 2026 [1]. This November 2026 update looks at what the tribunal decided, how it treated each valuer's work, and what executors, beneficiaries and solicitors in Kingston upon Thames and Surrey can take from it.
This article is general information only. It is not legal, tax or financial advice.
Key Takeaways
- The Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) set the inheritance tax value of the property at £670,000. That was £130,000 below HMRC's figure and £155,000 above the figure in the estate's return [1].
- The original probate report listed comparable sales but did not explain how they led to its figure.
- HMRC's expert was regarded as a good witness, yet his figure was still reduced because he did not test his end result against prices actually paid.
- A price per square metre can overstate the value of a property that is unusually large and in poor condition.
- A reasoned valuation at the start protects executors better than a low figure that cannot be defended later.
Key facts of the probate valuation dispute
The dispute was about the open market value of one leasehold maisonette at the date of death. The table sets out the facts confirmed in the published decision [1].
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Case | Peter Downey (The Estate of Mr Thomas Anthony Downey) v HMRC |
| Citation | [2026] UKUT 228 (LC) |
| Tribunal | Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) |
| Tribunal member | Mrs D Martin TD MRICS FAAV |
| Decision date | 26 June 2026 |
| Property | Maisonette at Boscombe Road, Shepherd's Bush, London W12 |
| Size and tenure | 117 sq m, no outside space, 95 years left on the lease |
| Valuation date | 20 April 2016 (the date of death) |
| Estate's return figure | £515,000 |
| HMRC determination | £800,000 |
| Tribunal's value | £670,000 |
| Outcome | Appeal allowed |
The appellant and his sister inherited the property from their uncle. A private valuation dated 23 May 2016 gave £515,000, and that figure went into the inheritance tax return. A Valuation Office Agency surveyor inspected on 31 January 2018 and put the value at £800,000. Negotiations failed. HMRC issued a formal determination at £800,000 on 23 July 2024, upheld it on review on 30 January 2025, and the estate appealed [1].
The legal test the tribunal applied
The test is the price the property might reasonably be expected to fetch if sold in the open market at the date of death. That wording comes from section 160 of the Inheritance Tax Act 1984 [2]. HMRC's formal decision on value is a notice of determination under section 221 of the same Act [3].
Appeals are governed by section 222. A question about the value of land in England and Wales is decided by the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber), a specialist valuation tribunal [4]. Here the decision was made by a chartered surveyor member. It cites no case law. It was decided on the valuation evidence alone [1].
How the expert evidence was treated
The tribunal did not adopt either side's figure. It tested each valuation against the comparable sales and reached its own view.
The estate's probate report
The 2016 report listed seven comparable sales from April 2015 to March 2016. It did not explain how those sales produced £515,000, and the tribunal found that the figure sat well below the sales evidence. The valuer who wrote the report did not give evidence at the hearing, so nobody could explain or defend the reasoning. A second report from the same firm, dated March 2025, was given no weight [1].
The tribunal still used the sales listed in that report, because they included some of the best comparables. The data was useful. The missing reasoning was the problem.
HMRC's expert valuer
The Valuation Office Agency surveyor had more than 37 years of experience. He analysed the sales on a price per square metre basis, adjusted for the date of sale using a local price index, and made percentage adjustments for features such as gardens and roof terraces. He arrived at £8,000 per sq m for a flat in good condition with no outside space, took off £1,000 per sq m for condition, and reached £819,000, rounded down to £800,000 [1].
The tribunal regarded him as a good expert with a sound grasp of the local market, and broadly accepted his rate for a flat in good condition. Two points still counted against the final number:
- Size. The best comparable with no outside space achieved £7,931 per sq m, but it measured only 79 sq m against 117 sq m for the subject property. A rate taken from a much smaller flat can push the answer too high.
- No sense check. The tribunal found that he did not stand back and ask whether the end figure was realistic. Ranked by price and not by floor area, £800,000 sat high in the range for flats in good condition with outside space.
He also accepted that his adjustments for outside space could not be demonstrated from the comparable sales [1].
The tribunal's own valuation
Four sales of flats with no outside space fell between £626,567 and £753,132. The property was in very poor condition and had one bathroom, so the tribunal placed it below a comparable at £677,508 and settled on £670,000. It reasoned that a buyer could spend at least £130,000 on refurbishment and still expect a later sale above £800,000 [1].
Evidence from after the date of death
The estate relied on estate agents' advice from 2018 and 2020, a 2025 listing and a 2026 sale agreed subject to contract. HMRC argued that only matters known at the valuation date should count. The tribunal admitted the material but treated it as support for its conclusion, not as decisive [1].
A list of comparable sales is not a valuation. The reasoning that links the sales to the final figure is what a tribunal tests.
Practical lessons for Kingston executors and their solicitors
The main lesson is to obtain a reasoned valuation at the outset from a valuer who could defend it. Many estates in Kingston, Surbiton, New Malden and nearby parts of Surrey include older houses and converted flats that have had little work done for decades. Condition, size and layout make simple price per square metre comparisons unreliable for such properties.
Practical points drawn from the decision:
- Ask for a written report that shows its working. It should set out the comparables, the adjustments and why the final figure follows.
- Record the condition at the date of death. Dated photographs and notes are hard to recreate later. In Downey the valuation date was 2016 and the hearing was in 2026.
- Check the result both ways. A valuer should compare the answer by floor area with whole prices actually paid.
- Keep evidence of repair costs. The estate said £113,494 had been spent on works, but the claim was unsupported [1].
- Think about who will give evidence. A report whose author is not called carries less weight.
- Do not assume the lowest figure is safest. The tribunal's value was £155,000 above the return figure.
Beneficiaries have an interest too. A value that is too high can mean more tax than necessary. A value that is too low can lead to an enquiry, delay and legal cost before the estate assets are distributed.
Resolving a probate valuation dispute before a hearing
Most disagreements with HMRC over a probate value are resolved between valuers, and a formal appeal is the last step. In Downey the stages were an inspection by the Valuation Office Agency, failed negotiations, a notice of determination, a review and then the appeal [1]. A report prepared in line with the RICS Red Book valuation standards helps at each stage, because the reasoning is already on paper [5].
FAQ
What happens if the sale price is higher than the probate value?
A later sale at a higher price does not by itself make the probate value wrong, because the test is the open market value at the date of death. It may prompt questions from HMRC. In Downey the tribunal treated later marketing evidence as support only [1]. Tax consequences depend on individual facts, so professional advice should be taken.
How to settle estate disputes?
Most valuation disputes in an estate settle by evidence and negotiation. A clear report from a chartered surveyor often narrows the gap with the Valuation Office Agency. Disagreements between beneficiaries about value can be handled by a jointly instructed valuer or by mediation. A tribunal or court decision is the last resort, as it adds delay and cost.
Does an estate need its own expert witness at the tribunal?
It is not compulsory, but the decision shows the risk of going without. The estate's original valuer did not give evidence, so his report could not be tested or explained. HMRC called an experienced valuer. An independent expert who has inspected the property and can justify each adjustment gives a tribunal firmer ground.
Conclusion
Downey v HMRC carries a clear message: in a probate valuation dispute, reasoning wins over assertion. The estate's low figure failed because it was unexplained. HMRC's high figure failed because it was not sense-checked. The tribunal's own analysis of the comparables decided the case.
Next steps for executors and solicitors dealing with property in the Kingston area:
- instruct a RICS registered valuer for a full written report at the date of death;
- keep photographs, surveys and repair quotations with the estate papers;
- if HMRC challenges the figure, ask the valuer to review the comparables before negotiations begin;
- take legal advice early if a notice of determination is issued, as appeal time limits apply.
References
- Peter Downey (The Estate of Mr Thomas Anthony Downey) v HMRC, UKUT 228 (LC), Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber), 26 June 2026 (The National Archives). caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
- Inheritance Tax Act 1984, section 160: market value (legislation.gov.uk). legislation.gov.uk.
- Inheritance Tax Act 1984, section 221: notices of determination (legislation.gov.uk). legislation.gov.uk.
- Inheritance Tax Act 1984, section 222: appeals against determinations (legislation.gov.uk). legislation.gov.uk.
- RICS Valuation Global Standards (Red Book). rics.org.




