Park Homes v Avison Young (2026) EWHC 2713 (BP): Valuer Negligence Claim Over Desktop Valuations and Lessons for Kingston (November 2026)

A stock audit charged at £50 per unit is one of five pieces of work now being fought over in a High Court dispute about roughly £8 million of funding. On 27 October 2026, Chief Master Shuman gave judgment in Park Homes Investments Limited v Avison Young (UK) Limited (2026) EWHC 2713 (BP), a valuer negligence claim about five reports on mobile homes produced between April 2020 and March 2022 [1]. The court refused to strike the claim out, but it did cut away part of the losses claimed. Nobody has yet been found negligent: the main questions go to trial.

Key takeaways

  • The claim continues, but in a narrower form. The strike-out application failed. Summary judgment was granted only on some losses linked to the April 2020 desktop valuation, and refused on the other four reports [1].
  • A valuation duty protects against overvaluation, not every risk in a deal. Losses caused by the funded company disposing of assets and keeping the proceeds fell outside the April 2020 valuation duty [1].
  • Instructions, stated assumptions and caveats matter. "Desktop", "Subject to Inspection" and an instruction to assume homes were not agreed for sale were all central to the arguments [1].
  • Expert valuation evidence will decide breach. The court said the valuation method and the permissible range are matters for expert evidence, and the claimant must set out its own figure or range [1].

What happened in the Park Homes valuer negligence claim?

Park Homes Investments Limited (PHIL) provided funding to companies in the Royale Group. In return it took title to identified mobile homes on residential parks, with contractual rights to require repurchase or substitution. PHIL advanced about £8 million in total under two main transactions, in April 2020 and January 2021 [1].

Avison Young (AY), a national practice of surveyors and valuers, was instructed several times to value the homes and to audit them physically. PHIL says the reports overstated value or failed to explain signs that homes were occupied or already sold. AY denies negligence. It says its work was limited by its instructions and that the losses came from Royale's conduct, a risk it was never engaged to guard against [1][2].

The five reports

Report Type of work Key facts recorded in the judgment
17 April 2020 Desktop valuation 38 homes valued as a single parcel at £5.75 million. No physical inspection. Not presented as a Red Book compliant valuation.
8 September 2020 Physical stock audit Purpose was to check homes were "in situ" against stock sheets. Fee of £50 per unit. No valuation.
19 January 2021 Valuation 87 homes valued at about £14.37 million. Marked "Subject to Inspection".
25 February 2021 Updated report after inspections Appendix recorded classifications such as "Sold", "SSTC" and "Owner Occupied". The valuation figure was unchanged.
March 2022 Combined audit and valuation Report stated that sales had been agreed on 69 units.

PHIL entered the first transaction on 20 April 2020, three days after the desktop report, and advanced about £3.2 million under the second on 21 January 2021, two days after the January report. It later learned that homes it believed were still subject to its arrangements had been sold to third parties, with the proceeds not accounted for. The claim was issued on 15 August 2025 [1].

What did the High Court decide?

AY applied to strike out the claim or, in the alternative, for summary judgment. PHIL applied to amend its case. The applications were heard on 7 and 8 May 2026 [1].

Strike out refused. AY argued that PHIL had not said what the correct valuation, or range of valuations, should have been. The Chief Master agreed there was "force in that criticism", but held that the essential elements of the claim were pleaded. The remedy was more detail, not dismissal. PHIL must now identify the valuation or range it contends for and the main ways in which the method is said to have fallen short [1].

Summary judgment granted in part on the April 2020 report. The April engagement was a desktop valuation of 38 homes treated as available for sale. AY had not been asked to investigate ownership, to check whether sales had completed, or to assess Royale's honesty or financial standing. The court applied the scope of duty approach from Manchester Building Society v Grant Thornton UK LLP (2021) UKSC 20 and held that losses from Royale's disposal of homes, retention of sale proceeds and default were a different risk from overvaluation [1]. As the judgment puts it:

"Taking AY's valuation of £5.75 million as correct leaves unchanged the consequences of Royale disposing of the homes or retaining the proceeds."

PHIL can still pursue a conventional claim that the £5.75 million figure was outside the range open to a reasonably competent valuer [1].

Summary judgment refused on the other four reports. For the September 2020 audit, the court drew a line. Investigating whether a sale had legally completed was a different exercise from a physical audit. But whether visible signs of occupation should have been noticed, reported and explained is a question for trial, and the inspection photographs and site notes will matter [1].

For January 2021, AY relied on an exchange about 29 homes described as "sold" in the schedule it was given. Its surveyor queried them, and PHIL's representative instructed AY to include them on the assumption that they were not agreed for sale. The court said the correspondence gave "substantial support" to AY's case, but the two sides read the exchange differently and that needs a trial [1].

For February 2021 and March 2022, the issue is how a valuer should treat information gathered on inspection. The court will have to decide whether it was enough to record it in an appendix, or whether its significance for value should have been explained and the figure reconsidered or qualified [1].

Amendments. A new allegation that AY had been orally told to look for "red flags" was refused. It had not appeared in the pre-action correspondence or the original pleading, and the phrase was too imprecise to define an extra duty. Amendments on causation and loss of chance were allowed [1][2].

Why does the ruling matter for anyone thinking about a valuer negligence claim?

The instruction defines the duty

The court looked at each report separately and asked what that piece of work was for. A desktop valuation rather than a physical survey is a limited exercise, and both parties knew it. A client who wants a valuer to check occupation or title needs to say so in the instruction.

The same logic applies to the standard of report. The April 2020 report "was not presented as a valuation compliant with the RICS Red Book" [1]. It is worth comparing a Red Book valuation with a desktop estimate before instructing.

Assumptions cut both ways

An express assumption can protect a valuer. Here, the instruction to treat 29 "sold" homes as not agreed for sale may give AY "a substantial answer" to parts of the case [1]. Clients should read every assumption in a report and ask what the figure would be if it turned out to be wrong.

Finding something is not the same as explaining it

After the February 2021 inspections, the report recorded homes as "Sold" and "Owner Occupied", yet the valuation did not move and no warning was added. Whether reasonable care required more prominence and explanation is, the court said, a professional question "upon which expert evidence is likely to be important" [1].

What role will expert evidence play in this valuer negligence claim?

AY argued that the overvaluation case should fail now because PHIL had not served an expert report. The court disagreed. PHIL accepted that expert valuation evidence will be needed at trial and said it had taken preliminary expert input before serving its claim. The Chief Master held [1]:

"The proceedings have not reached the stage for expert evidence. The reasonableness of AY's methodology, the appropriate approach to valuation and the permissible range are matters upon which expert evidence will be required."

Three points follow for surveyors who act as expert witnesses and for the solicitors who instruct them.

  1. Scope of duty is for the judge. Identifying the correct scope of duty "is a question for the court rather than expert evidence" [1]. An expert valuer gives an opinion on method, comparables, the figure and the range, and does not argue the law.
  2. The claimant needs a number. A claim that a figure was "outside the range" must identify the competing valuation or range. That work is done by an independent valuer, usually well before trial.
  3. The underlying records matter. An expert will need the site notes, photographs and emails showing what the original valuer saw and was told.

Under the Civil Procedure Rules, expert evidence is restricted to what is reasonably required to resolve the proceedings, an expert's duty is to help the court and overrides any obligation to the instructing party, and no expert report can be used without the court's permission [3].

What does this mean for owners, buyers and lenders in Kingston upon Thames and south-west London?

The case concerned mobile homes on residential parks, not houses or flats in Kingston. The principles are general and apply to any valuation instruction in the borough or wider south-west London.

  • Match the product to the decision. A desktop figure may suit a quick check. A lending, tax or dispute decision may need an inspection and a fuller report. This guide to a building survey versus a valuation survey explains what each does.
  • Know who the report is for. A lender's valuation is written for the lender's purpose. Buyers who want to understand how surveyor reports influence mortgage lending and down-valuations should not assume it covers condition or title.
  • Put the instruction in writing. State the purpose, whether there will be an inspection, and anything specific the valuer should check.
  • Tell the valuer what is known. If the valuer is told to assume something, the report will say so, and that assumption may later be relied on.
  • Keep the paper trail. Emails and call notes around a valuation can become the key evidence years later. More detail on formal reports is on the valuation reports London page.

Frequently asked questions

Did the court find that Avison Young was negligent?

No. This was a ruling on applications to strike out, for summary judgment and to amend. The court decided only which parts of the case can go to trial. Duty, breach, causation and loss remain to be decided [1].

Can a valuer be liable for something a desktop valuation could not have revealed?

The judgment suggests that is difficult. The April 2020 work was a desktop exercise without inspection, and the court held the duty was directed to the value of the assets, not to ownership or completed sales. A claim that the figure itself was outside the reasonable range remains open [1].

What does "Subject to Inspection" mean on a valuation report?

It signals that the figure was reached before a physical inspection and may need revisiting afterwards. In this case, one issue for trial is whether the later inspection findings should have led the valuer to reconsider or qualify the earlier figure [1].

Is an expert report needed before starting a claim against a valuer?

The court did not treat the absence of a served expert report as fatal at this early stage. It did make clear that expert evidence on method and range will be required, and that the claimant must set out the valuation or range it relies on [1].

Conclusion

Park Homes Investments v Avison Young is not the final word on this dispute, but it is already a useful guide. A valuer's responsibility is shaped by the instruction, the stated assumptions and the purpose of the report. Losses caused by a counterparty's conduct are unlikely to fall on a valuer who was only asked for a figure.

Practical next steps:

  1. Tell the valuer what decision the valuation will support.
  2. Check whether the report is desktop or inspected, and read its assumptions.
  3. If a valuation is in dispute, take legal advice early and obtain an independent expert view on the figure and the range.

This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Anyone affected by a valuation dispute should take advice on their own facts.

References

  1. Park Homes Investments Limited v Avison Young (UK) Limited (2026) EWHC 2713 (BP), Chief Master Shuman, 27 October 2026, The National Archives. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
  2. Solicitor News, "Avison Young Professional Negligence: High Court Ruling", 28 October 2026. solicitornews.co.uk.
  3. Civil Procedure Rules, Part 35: Experts and Assessors (rules 35.1, 35.3 and 35.4), Ministry of Justice. justice.gov.uk.
Kingston Surveyors logo
Copyright ©2024 Kingston Surveyors